Accommodations vs Modifications: How to Close Learning Gaps Without Lowering the Bar

Some of your students are reading below grade level. Some are still working on two-digit by one-digit multiplication when the curriculum expects three-digit by two-digit. The grade-level work feels too hard for them, so it’s tempting to simplify it. But is that accommodating, or is it modifying?

Why the line gets blurry

“Meet students where they are” is good advice. The problem is that it often turns into lowering what we expect. When we simplify the task so much that we’re doing most of the work, or hand a Grade 5 student a Grade 3 text and call their answer a B, we’ve modified the program. Unless a student has an IEP that says so, we’re still required to teach and assess the expectations for their grade.

The shift: keep the platform, extend the ladder

Picture yourself standing on the Grade 5 platform. Some students are up there with you. Others are still reaching for the edge. Modifying lowers the platform. Accommodating keeps it where it is and gives students a ladder, as long and as supported as they need, to climb up.

  • Accommodations change how a student learns or shows their learning. The expectation and the complexity stay at grade level.
  • Modifications change what a student is expected to learn, by simplifying the work or the expectations. They need an IEP and clear documentation.

Step 1: Accommodate the product

Students can show the same learning in different ways. In a Grade 5 human body unit, one student might write and perform a song, another might build a model of the heart, and another might write a report on how the heart and lungs work together. Each one still has to show Grade 5 knowledge and understanding.

Choice boards work in every subject. For a math warm-up, try a bingo card with nine problems that use different skills, and have students complete any three in a row. Every option is at grade level, but students have a say in how they get there.

Step 2: Accommodate the process

Students take different paths to the same goal. In writing, some students need to talk through their ideas, have someone poke holes in them and fill in an organizer before they write a word. Others write best by just starting. For them, the organizer becomes an editing tool: they go back and check their draft has all the parts of the plot.

In math, I always noticed I had list kids and picture kids. List kids solve problems with organized, step-by-step lists. Picture kids need to draw, model and build it. Forcing one group to work the other way just felt chaotic to them. So I teach and model both, talk with students about which kind of thinker they are, and teach several strategies, like partial products, the box method and the standard algorithm, rather than one “right” way.

Step 3: Accommodate the environment

Some students can’t focus in silence. Others can’t focus with any noise at all. You can offer noise-cancelling headphones to students who need quiet, and let others listen to music, as long as you monitor whether it actually helps them work. I like playing study music with a countdown timer on the board so students know how long they’re working for.

Flexible seating, working with a partner to bounce ideas around (or working alone, away from distractions) and chunking time into short work periods with breaks are all accommodations too. Where a student sits or whether they listen to music doesn’t give them an advantage. The quality of the work they produce is the same.

Step 4: Close gaps without lowering expectations

Instead of saying “this work is too hard for my students,” try “my students aren’t ready for this yet, but we’re going to get there.” Then:

  • Give them more practice at the skill. When writing was my class’s biggest gap, I had students write for at least 20 minutes every day, and I dropped some other centres to make room for it.
  • Give timely feedback. Conference with students, talk about what they’re working on next, and use bump it up walls and exemplars so students can see what level 3 work looks like.
  • Reteach the missing rungs. In math, you can’t move on if students have never seen multiplication. Go down the ladder, teach the concept they need, then build up to grade level. Number sense is usually the best place to focus, since everything else builds on it.
  • Give the mark they’ve earned, and be patient. You don’t need students at a level 3 in October. You need them there by June. Until then, a C or a D is an honest mark. Explain to parents where their child is and what your plan is.

A student reading below grade level can still be accommodated if they can show grade-level thinking about a text. If a student truly can’t access grade-level work, talk with your school team about whether they need an IEP. Without one, the expectations stay where they are.

For more, read 4 Classroom Differentiation Strategies.

Your next step

Try a free week of Ignited Literacy. Get a full week of ready-to-teach Grades 3–6 literacy lessons with differentiation built in. Get your free week

Learn more: Organize Your Literacy Block. Watch the free webinar to fit daily writing, conferences and small groups into your block. Save your seat

Want grade-level lessons in every subject? The Ignited Teaching All-Access membership gives you Ignited Literacy, Ignited Math and Ignited Lessons Club for Grades 3–6, aligned with the curriculum in every province. Explore All-Access

Patti

Patti Firth has been a teacher for over 20 years. She’s the founder of Madly Learning, home of the Ignited Teaching membership programs — Ignited Literacy, Ignited Math and Ignited Lessons Club — and Simply Graded.

You might also like...

Ignited Lessons cluB

Science & Social Studies Freebie

Ignited Math

Free Sample

Ignited Literacy

Free Sample
0